This is perfect timing for Tesla insurance

TeslaMondo talks to car buyers every day. Their car insurance falls into one of these two arrangements, and both of them create a not-so-fresh feeling.

CAMP ONE — big, abstract entities with no local agent. GEICO, Lib Mutual, Progressive, etc. When customers sign on with these companies, they know where their money is going. This doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a lovely relationship. But at least these customers know who handles their car insurance.

CAMP TWO — local agent. This is where things get dicey. Believe it or not, many customers can’t remember who their insurance agent is. They probably know the brand of insurance, such as Safety Insurance or Commerce, but not the local middleman who sells it to them. “The money goes somewhere,” they say. Then they whip out their cell phones and try to look it up, or they call someone at home to find out. Oftentimes, even their go-to source has the name totally wrong because the agency was bought out years ago by another agency. In short, the middleman offers no value. Even if you’re in an accident and call your agent, you’re immediately instructed to call the parent company. True?

People are migrating from camp 2 to camp 1, the lesser of the two evils. If the rates are even slightly better there, then goodbye local agent, whoever you are. Might as well send the money to a lizard, or that other creature.

Geico lady TeslaMondo

So your choices are either a phantom middleman who does nothing but pick your pocket, or a big, cold machine that picks your pocket a little less but poisons your world with gag-worthy marketing. Neither camp sounds terrific? Tesla may have a compelling alternative, assuming it takes its overseas insurance offerings to the USA:

CAMP THREE — Automaker insurance. The advent of autonomy is going to hurt the car insurance industry as car ownership declines and accidents become scarcer. Premiums should, in theory, fall dramatically, but of course they won’t — unless they’re FORCED to fall dramatically by disruptive intervention. If Tesla’s proprietary rates are cheaper than camp one, with comparable coverage, and with at least some semblance of personal relationship, why would anyone go another direction? Risk of a Tesla bankruptcy, maybe. Who underwrites Tesla insurance? There’s a question worth asking.

Another question worth asking is how much crack the press can possibly smoke before someone drags them away from their keyboards. First, Mashable writes a dubious click-me headline (Tesla insurance isn’t available in the US). Then EconoTimes links to the Mashable article but ups the ante by equating “insurance for life” with “life insurance.” Oy gevalt!


8 thoughts on “This is perfect timing for Tesla insurance

  1. H. G. Wells says:

    Finally PROOF that Tesla stock is going to ZERO !

    Insurance companies are smart. They know these cars are death traps. They accelerate FAR FAR too fast and their top speed is way above 70. That’s the real reason their rates are so HIGH.

    /S Long on TSLA but I do miss the interstate 55 MPH speed limit. It would let my Nissan Leaf get far better range while I wait for my Model 3


  2. An avid reader of the blog says:



  3. Brian says:

    Really quickly…(not really) …One of those big, abstract companies has a reputation for causing headaches for Tesla owners. I won’t give it away but you can figure it out via the online forums. Also, the famous man assoociated with the parent company of said insurance company is possibly Elon’s biggest rival for several major reasons I can think of right at the moment including…solar, electric vehicles and insurance and possibly more. Do you really want Elon’s rival getting money to insure your vehicle? Anyway, I digress…

    As for mom and pop agencies, some, like Jayson Hoffer in Arizona, an agent for one of the largest companies not mentioned, look out for their customers including making sure they have glass coverage quoted for their Tesla, which might be costly without it, not because it has the T on it of course. In fact, it seems Tesla loves glass.

    As far as who would underwrite Tesla insurance, with self-insurance for individuals and obviously corporations being “a thing” I’m sure the company itself or a handful of young billionaires could handle that. Take your pick!

    Go Tesla! Or…Go Home! Or maybe even stay for awhile playing nicely…then Go Home in Your Tesla!


  4. Timmy says:

    I bet even without any of the safety or autonomy features, that EV owner/drivers in general (and perhaps Teslarians in particular) are statistically better risks (less likely to make claims) than your average Josephine. We should get a discount for that, but as far as I know, no abstract entity or mom and pop offers one.

    “Second”, yes, Warren Buffet owns GEICO, etc. and who wants to give money to him!


  5. […] Originally published on TeslaMondo. […]


  6. […] Originally published on TeslaMondo. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s